February 24, 2017

GOP Healthcare and the Social Contract

Republican harping on God and Freedom, representing Government as a fairly unabashed evil, would have us forget the fundamental analysis of the Social Contract theorists that undergirded our founding generation's political understanding.

The fault of perfect Liberty is that it is unenjoyable, incommensurate with Life and the pursuit of Happiness, in the State of Nature. God may endow these unalienable Rights, but it is men who must secure them by banding together, consenting to renounce perfect Liberty to institute Governments.

This understanding is inscribed right in the Declaration of Independence:

"We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. -- That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed."

Republicans would have us remember the first part and forget the dash-bound second part. The absolute Freedom for each to choose and tailor their own healthcare is incommensurate with Life and the pursuit Happiness for all. Such a heedless absolute Freedom is nothing to which all would consent as a legitimating end of government. Republican healthcare would cast us back toward the State of Nature, which Thomas Hobbes represented as a "war of every man against every man,' wherein human life is "solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short."

(Comment on Paul Krugman, "Death and Tax Cuts" https://nyti.ms/2mfD97f)

Posted by Raoul

Why Bother

All Hail Freedonia!
Fragments
Google Giggles
Literacy and Its Discontents
Old and In the Way
On the Road
Pretty Vacant Video
Readers Notes
The Climate Suits My Clothes
The Net Takes You Nowhere
Time Keeps On Ticking
Weapons of Mass Distraction
Why indeed?

Links

Recent Posts

GOP Healthcare and the Social Contract
Fellow Travelers: Trump and Putin
Miss Congeniality
Voting Republican
The God Vote
Iraq: A Republican War
Neil Young's Articles of Impeachment
Neil Young, Living With War
Bush Baby-Boomers Take Care of Their Own
Bush's Social InSecurity Plan
A Fighting Faith
What I Really Said About Iraq
Skull & Bones A or Skull & Bones C
War Crime Planning
Good Christian Bush
Mission Accomplished
Too Many Notes
Every Vote Counts
(De)Manifest of April Fools Day 2000
Operation Enterprise


Advertising

Shameless
Self-Promotion

A few words about...
A few words about...
The little words cavorting noticed one day that they were being herded into an ever-narrower column in the middle of the page. To the left and the right appeared flickering changing shapes. One day, a group of words noticed that the shapes seemed to....
from Why Bother
Creative Commons License
This weblog is licensed under a Creative Commons License.

Copyright © 1998-2017
Why Bother | WhyBother.org